Rachel McAdams, Time Travel, and the Love Stories We Wish We Could Rewrite
By Johnny Spoiler | Binge-Watchers Podcast
As the holiday season approaches, I've been thinking about second chances.
It's a tough time of year for some people. The holidays have a funny way of reminding us of the people who aren't around anymore, the things we wish we'd done differently, and the moments we didn't realize were important until they were gone.
And sometimes you realize something even worse.
You don't get a second chance.
Which brings me to two movies starring Rachel McAdams, an actress who apparently has a contractual obligation to fall in love with men who travel through time.
Seriously.
She's played the romantic partner of a time traveler in four movies: The Time Traveler's Wife, Midnight in Paris, About Time, and Doctor Strange.
And in none of them does she get to do the time traveling herself.
Hollywood really looked at Rachel McAdams and said, "You know what she'd be great at? Waiting."
This week on Binge-Watchers Podcast, we're looking at two of those films: About Time (2013) and The Time Traveler's Wife (2009).
One is about changing the past. The other is about accepting that you can't.
Both are about love, loss, and the passage of time.
And one of them actually made me appreciate my father a little more.
About Time (2013): What If You Could Fix Every Mistake?
Johnny Spoiler Rating: BINGE LATER
Directed by Richard Curtis, About Time stars Domhnall Gleeson as Tim Lake, a young man who discovers on his 21st birthday that the men in his family can travel backward through time.
His father, played by Bill Nighy, explains this incredible family secret with the casual enthusiasm of a dad showing his son how to change a tire.
There's no spaceship. No DeLorean. No flux capacitor.
You just find a dark place, clench your fists, and think about a moment from your past.
Naturally, Tim decides to use this extraordinary gift to get a girlfriend.
Because apparently the ability to rewrite history is wasted unless you can use it to improve your dating life.
Love, Regret, and a Really Bad New Year's Eve
The movie opens with Tim failing to kiss a girl at midnight on New Year's Eve.
If you've ever been young, awkward, and romantically incompetent, you'll recognize this situation immediately.
The difference is that Tim gets to go back and try again.
Eventually, he moves to London, pursues a career in law, and meets Mary, played by Rachel McAdams.
Their first encounter happens at a restaurant where customers eat completely in the dark, served by visually impaired waiters.
Interestingly, a real London restaurant called Dans le Noir offers this kind of dining experience.
It's a terrific scene because Tim and Mary connect without seeing each other.
Then Tim makes the mistake of going backward through time to help a friend whose theatrical production has gone disastrously wrong.
He fixes the play.
But he erases the circumstances that brought him and Mary together.
That's the central problem with time travel.
You fix one thing, and suddenly you've broken something else.
The Kate Moss Problem
One of my favorite sequences involves Tim trying to recreate his first meeting with Mary.
He discovers she's attending a Kate Moss exhibition, and there's even a joke involving a naked Kate Moss photograph.
The movie understands that time travel would probably be used for incredibly ordinary, selfish reasons.
Nobody's first thought is preventing a major historical catastrophe.
It's getting the girl, avoiding embarrassment, or winning an argument you lost three days ago.
And I appreciate that kind of honesty.
When Time Travel Stops Being Fun
Eventually, About Time changes direction.
Tim tries to protect his sister from a series of terrible decisions, only to discover that altering the past can change the identity of his own child.
Suddenly, his gift isn't quite so wonderful.
He can't simply fix everyone else's problems without risking the life he's built.
The third act slows down considerably, and I'll admit the pacing starts to drag.
But the emotional payoff is worth discussing.
Tim's father has been using his time-travel ability for something much more meaningful than fixing dates or impressing women.
He's been spending more time with the people he loves.
And when Tim realizes that even time travel has limits, his final opportunities to revisit his father become the most important moments in the movie.
The real message isn't about changing the past.
It's about appreciating the present.
We're all so busy trying to get somewhere else that we forget to enjoy where we are.
It's charming, funny, and occasionally heartbreaking, but the final act loses some momentum. Still, Bill Nighy delivers a performance that gives the movie its emotional backbone.
The Time Traveler's Wife (2009): Love Without a Second Chance
Johnny Spoiler Rating: BINGE NOW
Now here's a movie I've watched three times.
I even own the DVD.
Have I read Audrey Niffenegger's novel?
Absolutely not.
But I've watched enough movies to know that books are dangerous. They have all those extra details and character development.
Directed by Robert Schwentke, The Time Traveler's Wife stars Eric Bana as Henry DeTamble, a Chicago librarian suffering from a rare genetic condition called chrono-displacement.
In plain English, Henry randomly travels through time.
He can't control when it happens.
He can't control where he goes.
And his clothes don't come with him.
Imagine having a medical condition that causes you to wake up naked in somebody else's backyard in 1983.
That's not a superpower.
That's a lifetime of explaining yourself to the police.
A Love Story Told Out of Order
Rachel McAdams plays Clare Abshire, a woman who has known Henry since she was a little girl.
The problem is that Henry hasn't met her yet.
An older version of Henry repeatedly visits Clare during her childhood, while his younger self eventually meets her as an adult.
Their relationship exists outside the normal rules of chronology.
For Clare, Henry has been part of her life for years.
For Henry, she's a complete stranger.
It's a fascinating premise because the two characters experience their relationship in completely different ways.
And unlike About Time, there's no easy reset button.
Big Events Pull Him Through Time Like Gravity
One of the movie's most interesting ideas is that major emotional events attract Henry through time.
They're like gravitational forces.
He doesn't necessarily travel to random moments. He's repeatedly pulled toward events that carry enormous significance in his life.
And here's the cruel part.
Knowing what's going to happen doesn't mean you can prevent it.
Henry can witness his future.
He can revisit his past.
But he can't rewrite the rules.
That's what makes this movie more tragic than About Time.
Tim has choices.
Henry has a destiny.
The Tragedy of Knowing Too Much
There's something deeply unsettling about knowing how your story ends.
Henry and Clare build a marriage around the uncertainty of when he'll disappear and when he'll return.
Their daughter, Alba, eventually inherits his condition.
And as the movie progresses, it becomes clear that certain events are unavoidable.
One particularly heartbreaking moment involves Henry's death and the suggestion that Alba has tried to intervene.
But the timeline doesn't bend.
No matter how badly these characters want a different ending, the future remains stubbornly intact.
That's the kind of science-fiction storytelling I appreciate.
The supernatural premise creates the circumstances, but the real horror comes from something completely human.
The inability to stop time.
Why I Prefer The Time Traveler's Wife
About Time is probably the more cheerful movie.
It's certainly the more optimistic one.
But The Time Traveler's Wife has a stronger emotional grip on me.
I like its fatalism.
I like that the characters can't simply erase their mistakes.
And I like the idea that love can remain meaningful even when you know it's temporary.
The film also has some fascinating production trivia.
Eric Bana had to delay reshoots because he'd shaved his head for Star Trek (2009), and the filmmakers needed his hair to grow back.
Imagine making a movie about a guy who travels through time and then having to wait nearly a year because the actor needs a haircut in reverse.
A beautifully melancholy romantic science-fiction movie about loving someone even when time itself refuses to cooperate.
About Time vs. The Time Traveler's Wife: Which Movie Wins?
Let's compare the two.
About Time gives its protagonist the ability to change his past, but eventually teaches him that happiness comes from appreciating ordinary moments.
The Time Traveler's Wife gives its protagonist knowledge of the past and future, but denies him the ability to change either.
One says life is precious because we can make different choices.
The other says life is precious because we can't.
And strangely enough, I find the second message more compelling.
MovieJohnny's RatingAbout Time (2013)BINGE LATERThe Time Traveler's Wife (2009)BINGE NOW
The Real Horror of Time Travel Is Running Out of Time
Here's where things get a little personal.
We're heading into the holidays.
People are making plans, buying presents, traveling to see family, and complaining about how expensive everything has become.
But somewhere out there, somebody is wishing they could have one more Christmas with their father.
One more conversation with an old friend.
One more ordinary afternoon with somebody they loved.
That's the part of these movies that stays with me.
Not the science fiction.
Not the romance.
The realization that we spend so much of our lives taking time for granted.
We assume there will always be another phone call, another visit, another holiday.
Until there isn't.
And no matter how many time-travel movies Hollywood makes, nobody has figured out how to give us those moments back.
So maybe the real lesson is to stop waiting for the perfect moment.
Enjoy the one you're in.
Even if it involves eggnog, terrible relatives, and questionable holiday decisions.
Listen to the Full Binge-Watchers Podcast Episode
Want more Johnny Spoiler movie reviews, time-travel theories, and questionable cinematic observations?
In the full episode, we also cover:
Joe Bob Briggs launching Coney Island Pictures and developing a new Basket Case.
Jason Voorhees returning in Jason, scheduled for Friday, August 13, 2027.
Johnny Knoxville joining a new Return of the Living Dead sequel.
A fan comparison between The Terror Within 2 and Alien: Romulus.
The Peoplebusters from The Real Ghostbusters and their return as collectible action figures.
Listen to Binge-Watchers Podcast on Spotify:
https://www.bwpodcast.com/listen-on-spotify
Visit the official website:
Binge-Watchers Podcast is hosted by comedian Johnny Spoiler, celebrating cult classics, forgotten horror movies, science fiction, and everything else Hollywood would probably prefer we forgot.
BINGE NOW. BINGE LATER. BINGE NEVER.
And remember, you don't have to go home, but you can't stay here.
Drink some eggnog. Make some bad holiday decisions.
Just don't make any you wish you could travel back in time to fix.
I'm checking out Total Brain Boost, a supplement marketed for brain health, memory, and focus. https://tr.ee/jTOTALBRAINBOOST
Try Lick Energy https://tr.ee/LickEnergy
This is an affiliate promotion, so I may earn a commission if you buy through my link.